The open circuit test stands as one of the most fundamental diagnostic procedures in transformer testing, serving as a cornerstone for understanding transformer behavior under no-load conditions. This standardized test provides critical insights into core losses and magnetizing characteristics without requiring the transformer to operate under actual load, making it both economical and practical for determining essential performance parameters.
What is Open Circuit or No Load Test?
The open circuit test, also known as the no-load test, determines the core losses and no-load circuit parameters of a transformer by measuring electrical quantities when the secondary winding remains open-circuited while rated voltage is applied to the primary winding. During this test, the secondary winding of the transformer (typically the high-voltage side) is left completely open, meaning no current flows through it, while the primary winding (usually the low-voltage side) receives its rated voltage from an AC supply.
This configuration creates a condition where the transformer draws only a small no-load current from the supply, typically ranging from 2-5% of the full-load current. Because the secondary carries no current and the primary current remains very small, copper losses become negligible, allowing the wattmeter to measure almost exclusively the core losses that remain constant regardless of load conditions. The test provides accurate measurements of iron losses, magnetizing current, and the shunt branch parameters of the transformer’s equivalent circuit.
Why Perform the Test on the Low Voltage Side
A critical aspect of conducting the open circuit test involves the choice to perform measurements on the low-voltage winding rather than the high-voltage winding. This practice stems from two important considerations that enhance both safety and measurement accuracy.
First, applying rated voltage to the low-voltage side proves far more convenient and safer than energizing the high-voltage side. For instance, applying 120V or 240V on the LV side is significantly more manageable than dealing with voltages that might reach several thousand volts on the HV side. This reduces the risk to personnel and simplifies the testing setup.
Second, the no-load current magnitude becomes more readily measurable when referred to the low-voltage side. Since the impedance of the shunt branch (representing core loss resistance and magnetizing reactance) appears much lower when referred to the low-voltage side, the resulting current flows at levels that standard ammeters can easily and accurately measure. If the test were conducted from the high-voltage side, the no-load current would be inconveniently small, making precise measurements difficult and potentially introducing significant measurement errors.
Equipment Required for Testing
Conducting an accurate open circuit test requires specific measuring instruments and safety equipment. The essential equipment includes:
Primary Measurement Instruments:
- AC Voltmeter: Measures the applied primary voltage (V₁), ensuring it matches the rated voltage specification
- AC Ammeter: Records the no-load current (I₀) flowing through the primary winding
- Low Power Factor Wattmeter: Measures the input power (W₀), which represents core losses under no-load conditions
Additional Equipment:
- Variable Voltage Source (Variac): Allows gradual voltage adjustment from zero to rated voltage, providing control over the test conditions
- Connecting Wires: Appropriate gauge wires rated for the test voltage and current levels
- Safety Equipment: Insulated gloves, safety glasses, and proper grounding connections
The wattmeter used must be specifically designed for low power factor measurements since the no-load power factor of transformers typically ranges from 0.1 to 0.3, which is significantly lower than unity. Standard wattmeters designed for unity or high power factor applications may not provide accurate readings under these conditions.
Detailed Testing Procedure
The systematic execution of the open circuit test follows a carefully structured sequence to ensure accurate results and maintain safety throughout the procedure.
Pre-Test Preparations
Before beginning the test, several critical preparatory steps must be completed. First, verify that the transformer has been thoroughly inspected for any physical damage, particularly examining the windings, terminals, and core for signs of deterioration or contamination. Essential preliminary tests, including insulation resistance tests and winding resistance measurements, should be completed beforehand to confirm the transformer’s basic electrical integrity.
Ensure the transformer is completely de-energized and properly isolated from any electrical system. Verify that all measuring instruments have been recently calibrated and are functioning correctly. Establish proper grounding connections for both the transformer frame and testing equipment to prevent electrical hazards.
Circuit Connection Setup
The circuit arrangement for the open circuit test requires precise connections to obtain accurate measurements. Connect the low-voltage winding terminals to the output of a three-phase or single-phase variable voltage source (variac), depending on the transformer type. The variable source input connects to the main AC supply through appropriate circuit breakers or isolators.
Insert the wattmeter’s current coil in series with the primary winding, ensuring correct polarity markings are observed. Connect the wattmeter’s voltage coil across the primary terminals. Place the ammeter in series with the primary circuit to measure the no-load current. Connect the voltmeter across the primary winding terminals to monitor the applied voltage. For three-phase transformers, if the LV side uses a wye connection, measure phase-to-neutral voltage; if delta-connected, measure phase-to-phase voltage.
Leave the high-voltage winding completely open-circuited, with no connections to its terminals except for an optional voltmeter that can verify the induced secondary voltage and confirm the turns ratio. Ensure all connections are tight and secure to prevent contact resistance from affecting measurements.
Conducting the Test
With the circuit properly connected, begin the actual test by following these steps methodically. Start with the variac output set to zero voltage. Close the main supply circuit breaker or switch. Gradually increase the variac output voltage from zero, monitoring the voltmeter reading continuously.
Raise the voltage in incremental steps—typically 20V intervals for transformers with ratings up to 120V, or proportionally larger steps for higher-voltage units. At each voltage level, allow the readings to stabilize for a few seconds, then record the voltmeter reading \((V₁)\), ammeter reading \((I₀)\), and wattmeter reading \((W₀)\). Continue increasing the voltage until reaching the rated voltage of the transformer.
At rated voltage, hold steady and take final measurements with particular care, as these represent the critical operating point. Record all three instrument readings simultaneously. If conducting the test for research or detailed analysis purposes, you may take readings at several voltage levels above and below rated voltage to plot characteristic curves.
Throughout the test, observe the transformer for any abnormal conditions such as unusual noise, vibration, excessive heating, smoke, or discharge phenomena. If any abnormalities occur, immediately reduce the voltage to zero and disconnect the supply before investigating the cause.
After completing measurements at rated voltage, gradually reduce the variac output back to zero voltage before opening the main supply switch. This controlled shutdown prevents voltage transients that might damage equipment or affect measurement accuracy.
Calculating Test Parameters
The open circuit test yields three direct measurements—voltage \((V₁)\), current \((I₀)\), and power \((W₀)\)—from which several important transformer parameters can be calculated using straightforward formulas.
Core Loss and No-Load Power Factor
The wattmeter reading directly provides the core loss or iron loss of the transformer:
\( P_i = W_0 \)
This represents the total power consumed to overcome hysteresis and eddy current losses in the magnetic core.
The no-load power factor can be calculated from the measured quantities:
\( \cos \phi_0 = \frac{W_0}{V_1 I_0} \)
This power factor is typically very low, ranging from 0.1 to 0.3 lagging, indicating that the no-load current is predominantly reactive in nature, required mainly for magnetizing the core.
Current Components
The no-load current I₀ consists of two orthogonal components. The working component (also called the active or core loss component) accounts for the power dissipated in core losses:
\( I_w = I_0 \cos \phi_0 = \frac{W_0}{V_1} \)
The magnetizing component (reactive component) produces the magnetic flux in the core:
\( I_m = I_0 \sin \phi_0 = \sqrt{I_0^2 – I_w^2} \)
The magnetizing component is typically much larger than the working component since the no-load power factor is quite low.
Equivalent Circuit Parameters
The shunt branch parameters of the transformer’s equivalent circuit can be determined from the test results. The core loss resistance R₀ represents the resistance that would dissipate power equal to the core losses:
\( R_0 = \frac{V_1}{I_w} = \frac{V_1^2}{W_0} \)
The magnetizing reactance X₀ represents the inductive reactance of the magnetizing branch:
\( X_0 = \frac{V_1}{I_m} \)
These parameters, when referred to the same side of the transformer where the test was conducted, form the parallel or shunt branch of the transformer equivalent circuit. If parameters referred to the opposite side are needed, they must be multiplied by the square of the turns ratio.
Interpreting Test Results
Understanding what the test measurements reveal about transformer condition and performance requires careful analysis and comparison with established criteria.
Normal vs. Abnormal Readings
For a healthy transformer operating under normal conditions, the no-load current typically ranges from 2% to 5% of the full-load rated current. Values significantly higher than this range may indicate problems such as shorted turns in windings, deteriorated core insulation allowing increased eddy currents, or partial core saturation.
The no-load power factor should fall within the range of 0.1 to 0.3 for most power transformers. Values substantially higher than expected might suggest increased core losses due to damaged laminations or contamination. Conversely, unusually low power factors could indicate measurement errors or equipment problems.
Unequal currents in the three phases of a three-phase transformer test may indicate short-circuited turns or winding faults. Ideally, the three-phase no-load currents should be nearly equal, with variations typically not exceeding 5% from the average value.
Comparison with Standards
Test results should be compared against multiple references to assess transformer health. First, compare measurements with the manufacturer’s factory test reports or nameplate data to determine if the transformer performs as originally designed. Second, compare with previous periodic test results taken under similar conditions to identify trends over time. A variation of more than 5% from previous tests taken under the same conditions may indicate an internal fault requiring further investigation.
Third, compare with relevant industry standards such as IEEE, IEC, or national electrical codes that specify acceptable limits for no-load losses, magnetizing current, and other parameters based on transformer type and rating.
Worked Example
To illustrate the practical application of open circuit test calculations, consider the following example based on typical test conditions.
Problem: An open-circuit test was performed on a 5 kVA, 200/400 V, 50 Hz single-phase transformer. The test was conducted on the low-voltage side with the high-voltage side kept open. The following readings were obtained: voltmeter reading \(V₁ = 200 V\), ammeter reading \(I₀ = 1.5 A\), and wattmeter reading \(W₀ = 100 W\). Determine the core loss, no-load power factor, current components, and equivalent circuit parameters.
Solution:
(a) Core Loss (Iron Loss): The wattmeter reading directly gives the core loss: \( P_i = W_0 = 100 W \)
(b) No-load Power Factor:
\( \cos \phi_0 = \frac{W_0}{V_1 \times I_0} = \frac{100}{200 \times 1.5} = 0.3333 (lagging) \)
(c) Working Component of No-load Current:
\( I_w = \frac{W_0}{V_1} = \frac{100}{200} = 0.5 A \)
(d) Magnetizing Component of No-load Current:
\( I_m = \sqrt{I_0^2 – I_w^2} = \sqrt{1.5^2 – 0.5^2} = \sqrt{2.25 – 0.25} = 1.414 A \)
(e) Core Loss Resistance:
\( R_0 = \frac{V_1}{I_w} = \frac{200}{0.5} = 400 Ω \)
(f) Magnetizing Reactance:
\( X_0 = \frac{V_1}{I_m} = \frac{200}{1.414} = 141.4 Ω \)
Practical Applications and Importance
The open circuit test serves multiple critical purposes in transformer engineering and maintenance, extending well beyond simple parameter measurement.
Efficiency Determination
One of the primary applications involves calculating transformer efficiency without actually loading the transformer. Since core losses remain constant at all load levels (when voltage is constant), the open circuit test provides the fixed loss component needed in efficiency calculations:
\( Efficiency = \frac{Output Power}{Output Power + Core Losses + Copper Losses} \times 100% \)
Voltage Regulation Assessment
The shunt branch parameters \((R₀\) and \(X₀)\) obtained from the open circuit test contribute to voltage regulation calculations. Voltage regulation measures how well a transformer maintains constant secondary voltage as load current varies:
\( Voltage Regulation = \frac{V_{no-load} – V_{full-load}}{V_{full-load}} \times 100% \)
Transformer Health Assessment
Regular open circuit testing during transformer operation provides valuable diagnostic information about the condition of the core and insulation system. A significant increase in no-load current or core losses compared to previous test results or manufacturer specifications may indicate deterioration of the core insulation, short-circuited laminations, or other internal faults requiring investigation. If measured exciting current exceeds 50 times the value from pre-commissioning tests, serious winding faults may exists.
Open Circuit Test Parameter Calculator
Quiz on Open Circuit Test
Conclusion
The open circuit test represents an essential diagnostic tool in transformer engineering, providing critical information about core losses, magnetizing characteristics, and equivalent circuit parameters through a simple, safe, and economical procedure. By conducting the test on the low-voltage side with the secondary open-circuited, one can accurately measure iron losses that remain constant across all loading conditions, determine the no-load power factor and current components, and establish the shunt branch parameters needed for comprehensive performance analysis